01 / OVERVIEW
User Experience (UX) Design I
User Experience (UX) Design I explored the use of case studies to further expand upon the principles of UX that were learned in a previous course.
My second course in the certificate, I explored the user pain points of navigating the popular bookseller website, powells.com. Generally, the navigation on the website in both desktop and mobile is a bit confounding, the footer is hidden on mobile, there is some slight and unintentional horizontal scrolling on mobile, and the first page itself is really long and overwhelming. The website doesn’t seem complete and also doesn’t utilize the amazing layout of the physical store either which may very well be a missed opportunity. This site falls under the umbrella of content source or task based website/e-commerce.
I took this course during the Winter of 2021. During the course, I created a case study report, wireframes, and a prototype of how the website could be improved.
02 / CONTEXT
Case Studies to Understand User Pain Points
Using user research (through the use of a survey,) I discovered quite a few pain points when navigating the powells.com website. Afterwards drafting a case study that covered at least 3 user defined points that could prove to be advantageous to the business if implemented.
03 / EXPLORING USER PAIN POINTS
1. Navigation Layout and Problems
There are a couple inaccuracies with the main navigation. It jumps from a smaller mid page navigation on the front page to full page navigation when clicking a couple of the pages within the site. It isn’t consistent on what pages are full page and which are not. The drop down menus also utilize very small text and no metaphors are used other than the search icon above the nav bar (which is located at the top of the page in an expected place.)
To create an account, you will need to click on login and there isn’t any indication that this is where to create an account, this option is also very small in the upper right corner. Even though it is in an expected place in the nav, it doesn’t use a metaphor for ‘Login’ nor ‘Cart.’ Once in the account area, the navigation opens up to include more options above just ‘Login’. Why aren’t these options available on every page including the home?
2. Mobile Isn’t Stable
Viewing the site via a mobile device, the site doesn’t sit tightly within the viewport. It can float around horizontally. While scrolling this is incredibly evident. The footer isn’t always visible via mobile devices especially iPhone users. It does show up on a couple pages but, it isn’t consistent which page it is shown. It is not shown on the home page though.
Small text in the hamburger menus can also be an issue. When tapping on a menu item, it will take you to the page requested, however, if you just want to close the menu, there isn’t an X to close it out. Tapping outside the hamburger menu box doesn’t close it as well. Tapping on the ‘Browse’ page is also problematic. Once the page is loaded, the hamburger menu gets smaller, it sits next to the Search bar (almost on top of it,) and the Search bar can be accidentally tapped because the entire page within the viewport becomes smaller. This does not occur when viewing the same page via desktop.
3. Overall Design Looks Dated and Unfinished
The site design overall has a dated and unfinished look that may turn away some users and potential customers. The long scroll (on both desktop and mobile) of most pages is overwhelming without a sticky header and a back to top button isn’t available. Having too many options can be frustrating because of how much is offered to the user all at once.
The sidebars are also inconsistent page to page and the site doesn’t seem to have a cohesive layout page to page. Social media links seem like an afterthought on most pages.
04 / CASE STUDY
Development Of The Powells Case Study Report
The Powells.com website needs a bit of an update!
After compiling the pain points of users and visitors to powells.com via a google survey, a case study report was created outlining these pain points and providing solutions to them as well. The case study also explored similar sized competitors and laid out what layout advantages they had over powells.
To better understand the user journey, I created wireframes to help visualize this and to create what could be improved with a few minor changes to the website.
For the wireframe, it was advantageous to have something to showcase that would be easily implemented and also easy to navigate.
04 / WIREFRAME
Once the Case Study was Complete, Wireframes Were Developed.
The wireframes that were developed after the case study report was complete, further exploring visually how the user based improvements to the site could be implemented.
This included a better navigation, more cohesive layout, and a better mobile experience.
05 / PROTOTYPE
Prototyping the Website
After creating the wireframes, a prototype was created in Adobe XD. This prototype included a better website layout with logical sections, a better designed navigation, and a more stable mobile experience. Due to time constraints, it was a fairly basic walkthrough of what could potentially be available to the user.
Shown here is just a snapshot of what is possible with this website, what is possible with a layout update, and it’s behavior.
06 / MOBILE
Mockups of How the Website Looks on a Mobile Device
To fully see how this website would look on a mobile device mockups on an iPhone were created to help visualize it.
07 / REPORT
Reporting the Findings
After creation of the prototype, a presentation/report was created. This report outlined reasonings and gave a concise visual representation of the steps taken to improve the website.
08 / RESULTS & OUTCOMES
What Was Learned
Wish the website could have actually been updated
This project was incredibly fun to work through. Especially when looking through the data provided from a small sample of users. This allowed me to fully have an understanding of best practices when questioning users about how they felt when exploring a website (and finding pain points and problems.) I do wish I had the opportunity to speak to the folks at Powells about what I discovered. (Sadly, they have been experiencing some staffing trouble, and I didn’t want to add to their strife.)
PREVIOUS PORTFOLIO ITEM
NEXT PORTFOLIO ITEM